I have been re-reading Prahalad's book on the fortune
at the bottom of the pyramid lately. The thesis of the book, which I
wholeheartedly subscribe to, is that there is a big opportunity to turn
back the scourge of poverty by providing services and technology to the
large percentage of the world's population living somewhere around the
poverty line. These services and technology are not provided as charity
but as profitable business operations. An interesting corollary, of
course, is that if you can find a way to provide profitable services to
people living on less than one dollar a day, you will also probably have
developed business models and practices, which should even be more
profitable when serving customers living at a thousand dollars or more per
day.
In the financial sector, Grameen Bank in Bangladesh and
ICICI in India are show cased as companies finding innovative ways to
exploit this bottom of the pyramid market. In Africa, the bottom of the
pyramid market is even bigger than elsewhere on the planet. In theory
therefore, the fortune at the bottom of the pyramid here will even be
richer. If Nigeria were a barometer of the rest of the continent, it is
safe to say that the FIs on the continent have largely ignored this
segment.
Services and technology from the financial sector have
focused almost exclusively to serving the needs of the lower middle class
to upper classes in the society. The rage is all for private banking,
credit cards, Internet banking and ATM cards, wealth management and all
the other services that make sense to customers far from the bottom of the
pyramid.
Discussing this once with a banker friend, he did a
back-of-the-envelope calculation to show me that providing services to
this segment is not profitable. Imagine the cost of providing a chequebook
and processing cheques for a customer with no more than $50 in her account
and turnover of not more than $200 in a year. He insisted it is a dead
end. The recent surge of MFIs did little to convince him. I got his
attention when I pointed out that there is actually, in most countries, an
informal banking sector which has been servicing this sector. In Nigeria,
they are called daily contribution operators. Therefore, you can save ten
to twenty cents a day for a long period. You can take out loans depending
on the level of your saving or the guarantee your group can provide.
The operators visit their subscribers in their homes
and their places of work that is, the bank follow the customer to where
ever he is. He is also a counselor, a friend, a motivator and a member of
the community. He understands the needs of the community. He understands
the needs of the subscribers. Can the big banks utilise this model?
Technology, of course, can make it possible. The banks
can recruit and empower daily contribution operators who will in effect
operate as agents for the banks. With a personal digital assistant (PDA)
or a phone, the operators can keep records of the contributions, cash
withdrawals and loans of the subscribers. These records can be
synchronised with the banks' central servers at intervals or online using
GPRS and 3G mobile services increasingly available across the continent.
Records can also be kept on smartcards with the subscribers. Such
smartcards can be used to effect P2P payment, money transfer and identity
management. Technology alone will not, of course, solve all these
problems. However, by enabling the existing informal business, the banks
can easily penetrate and enable the entire sector. In fact, the peculiar
needs of this sector may lead to the creation of a situation where banking
services will be provided by traditionally non-financial institutions.
For instance, retail chains providing credit in Brazil
or Cemex credit for house building and cement purchase. In Nigeria for
instance, a motor cycle manufacturer can easily seed the market with
credit for the commercial motor cycle operators. In Nigeria, the telecoms
market is a pre-paid market. If the telcos were to start paying interest
on the prepayments they receive, they would easily become a massive bank
with access to customer base in the tens of millions. The telcos' platform
can easily provide additional services like P2P payment, and with their
network of agents and dealers, they can also offer services like
micro-loans, which typically require face time with the customer.
Interestingly, Grameen Bank has used similar synergy to
create GrameenPhone. I am waiting for the first bank to collaborate with a
telco to provide services to the market at the bottom of the pyramid.
